A little about Governor Tom McCall

Given that Tom McCall would have turned 100 about a week ago, I thought I’d share a little excerpt about McCall from my masters thesis on the Mt. Hood Freeway. It’s short, but gets to the point that McCall begged off on putting the final nail in the coffin of the freeway. Perhaps it was because he understood the political ramifications in the fact that the freeway was actually quite popular outside of inner Southeast Portland.

Here’s that excerpt:

In late November 1974, outgoing Governor McCall notified the head of the Federal Highway Administration, Norbert Tiemann, and U.S. Secretary of Transportation, Claude S. Brinegar, that he concurred with the recommendations of CRAG, the City of Portland, Multnomah County, and his own task force on transportation that the Mount Hood Freeway be removed from the federal interstate system.[1] McCall’s communication with the highway administration was still not a formal application for withdrawal. The popular yet term-limited governor elected to leave that maneuver up to his successor, Democrat Robert Straub, who during his campaign for governor had acknowledged his opposition to the freeway’s construction.[2] While it may have seemed that McCall’s actions sealed the fate of the freeway, his maneuver left open a window of opportunity for pro-freeway forces to qualify a ballot initiative requiring a public vote on the issue.[3]



[1] Tom McCall to Claude S. Brinegar, 26 November 1974, Box 117, Folder 2, Goldschmidt Papers, http://arcweb.sos.state.or.us/governors/goldschmidt/box117/goldschmidt_117_002.pdf (accessed September 29, 2008).

[2] Tom McCall to Norbert Tiemann, 26 November 1974, Box 117, Folder 2, Goldschmidt Papers, http://arcweb.sos.state.or.us/governors/goldschmidt/box117/goldschmidt_117_002.pdf (accessed September 29, 2008).

[3] Tom McCall, letter to the editor, The Oregonian, December 5, 1974. 

Freeways and the Portland-Vancouver Metropolitan Transportation Study

Portland-Vancouver Metropolitan Area Transportation Study - Map of existing, committed, and proposed roadway improvements, c.1969-70.

Portland-Vancouver Metropolitan Transportation Study – Map of existing, committed, and proposed roadway improvements, c.1969-70.

Because the topic seems to be of ongoing interest, I thought I’d share a bit of the text from My MA Thesis on the Mt. Hood Freeway. Contact me if you’d like to read more.

Excerpt from: IN THE SHADOW OF A CONCRETE FOREST: TRANSPORTATION PLANNING, ENVIRONMENTAL POLITICS, AND THE REVOLT AGAINST THE MOUNT HOOD FREEWAY, 1955-1976 by Val C. Ballestrem

In addition to Portland’s local planning efforts, the highway department enlisted the Portland Vancouver Metropolitan Transportation Study (PVMTS) group. Originally formed in 1959, PVMTS helped direct local freeway development. At the helm was long-time Portland city commissioner William Bowes, a staunch proponent of the Laurelhurst Freeway and freeways in general. Bowes had overseen the Portland Public Works Department since 1939, fancying himself a sort of Robert Moses-like figure. In fact, Bowes had played a role in bringing New York City’s famous “power broker” and freeway builder to Portland in 1943.[1] Citing local traffic studies dating back to 1949, which asserted the need for north-south traffic relief between 39th and 52nd Avenues, Bowes and the PVMTS recommended construction of the Laurelhurst – Lake Oswego route for I-205.

On April 2, 1963, the efforts of the PVMTS and the highway department were rejected by the Lake Oswego City Council. In unanimously resolving to oppose any freeway that would pass through its jurisdiction, the Lake Oswego City Council told the highway department and PVMTS to “forget about” building any freeway within a distance of several miles of their city.[2]  Because state law forbid the highway department from building roads through any jurisdiction that did not give approval, the PVMTS, under the watchful eye of Laurelhurst Freeway advocate William Bowes, had to select another connection to I-5 at its western end. One solution was the Mount Hood Freeway, which was also part of the highway department’s 1955 freeway plan for the Portland metropolitan area and a route that had plenty of official support.

Lake Oswego’s rejection of I-205 invigorated plans for the Mount Hood Freeway. Although the general route for a potential Mount Hood Freeway had been agreed on by Portland and Multnomah County officials as early as 1956, efforts at developing the Mount Hood route had been repeatedly stymied. Because the route was too close to Portland’s city center, the Mount Hood Freeway did not meet federal standards for interstate bypass loop segments. As a general guideline, the Bureau of Public Roads (BPR), which oversaw implementation of the interstate network, wanted highway segments to avoid city centers, by looping around urban areas rather than through them. The BPR had refused to consider the Mount Hood option as a substitute for I-205, because I-205 had always been viewed primarily as a north-south outer bypass route.[3] Using the Mount Hood route as part of I-205 would mean the BPR would have to change its policy of keeping outer bypass loops away from city centers. If the Mount Hood Freeway was to become part of the interstate system, it would have to be deemed one of the main-line interstate routes for Portland, rather than a portion of a bypass loop.[4] Portland’s existing east-west interstate line was the heavily traveled Banfield Freeway, completed for the most part prior to the 1956 Interstate Highway Act. This route, also designated I-80 North, did not meet federal interstate standards because of its narrow lanes and sharp curves, which provided proponents of the Mount Hood route an opportunity to redouble their freeway advocacy efforts.

[1] Abbott, Portland: Planning, Politics, and Growth, 138.

[2] Oregon Journal, April 3, 1963.

[3] I-80N Environmental Study Freeway Design Alternatives, Volume 1, 13.

[4] Ibid., 14.

Another 1955 View of Proposed Portland Freeway System

Here’s another view from the 1955 freeway plan for Portland. This time we’re looking north along the Willamette River. Note that the Fremont Bridge is imagined in this scene. A Fremont (or vicinity) bridge had been in the idea phase since the 1920s. You can also see the proposed East Bank Freeway, pretty close to its final alignment several years later. This alignment was actually counter to recommendations in the 1940s by the renowned Robert Moses. He suggested that a north south “thruway” or freeway if you will,  should be aligned at around 7th Avenue on Portland’s east side.

Memories of the Mt. Hood Freeway Sought

In the past 50 years, perhaps no single event altered the course of the city than the lengthy battle over the Mt Hood Freeway. From the mid-1950s into the late 1970s, the specter of the Mt. Hood Freeway hung over Southeast Portland and in neighborhoods, from the Willamette River east to beyond I-205, there remain hints to this day at what might have been.

The Mt. Hood Freeway was a divisive issue throughout the Portland area and it is time that the whole story of the freeway be brought to light. Were you here in Portland when the freeway battle was in full swing? Whether you were for or against the Mt. Hood Freeway and whether you participated in this “freeway revolt” or simply lived in its path, I’d like to hear from you. Over the next several months I’ll be gathering your memories with the hope of writing a book or at least an article for the Oregon Historical Quarterly about this momentous event in Portland’s transportation history.

I’ve thoroughly researched the public documents, reports, and newspaper articles related to the proposed freeway. My MA thesis was about the freeway and in addition to this article I wrote for the Oregon Encyclopedia, I have given several public talks about the freeway.  But I still I need more insight from those who were actually there. If you have stories you’d like to share, you can just add your comments to this blog post or send an email to my address below and we can discuss it further.

I’ll continue to update this site with some of the history that I’ve already uncovered, including images like this one from a 1955 Oregon Highway Division report showing (among other things) a proposed Mt. Hood Freeway for the first time:

1955 aerial photo depicting Mt. Hood Freeway and several other possible freeway routes in Portland.
Source: Freeway and Expressway System: Portland Metropolitan Area (1955)

Thanks for visiting PortlandHistorian.com!

Welcome to PortlandHistorian.com

Thanks for checking out my new website. In the coming months I hope to add a lot more content to the site. In the meantime, if you have any questions about Portland history, please send them my way. Initial consultations are free!

Val

Portlandhistory@gmail.com

 on Twitter